Claims

CONFIDENT PRECISE PROTECTION

THE CLAIMS PROCESS

Being the subject of an insurance claim can be an overwhelming experience. We understand how you may feel. After all, we have been facilitating the claims process for the accounting profession for over 35 years. With decades of experience, we are uniquely skilled at guiding you through the process, so that you can get back to your practise and continue to serve your clients.

Your policy contains a formal definition. However, in simple terms, a claim is an allegation of wrongdoing that results in damages to another party and there is a request, or sometimes a demand, for restitution.

It is very important that you report any claim or potential claim to us without delay. It is important to remember not to admit liability and to notify CPA PLI of any developments immediately.

A potential claim could come in the form of a complaint from a client, or it could be more formal, like a lawsuit, or subpoena. Both scenarios must be reported.

Avoid trying to fix it yourself. Promptly report any allegation of an error, or an omission in the performance of professional services. The timing of reporting may impact your coverage, so prompt attention is extremely important.

After submitting the claim form, a Claims Examiner will be assigned to assist you through the entire process. Facilitating the claims process for accountants is what they do.

Your Claims Examiner will assess the claim presented and the coverage available. They will evaluate liability based on the circumstances described, and consider any applicable laws or regulations that may apply.

In some cases, we may seek insights and assistance from external experts such as legal counsel, independent adjusters or other professionals. For example, their assistance may be required to assess complex issues related to coverage, damages and/or liability.

We will estimate the damages associated with your claim. This involves an in-depth analysis of the impact of the allegations raised and the damages being claimed by other parties.

Once all the assessments are complete, the negotiation process begins. This involves discussions with you and, if necessary, any third parties involved to reach a mutual agreement on handling and resolving the claim. The final step in the claims process is resolution.

Jack Daiter

VP, Claims and Risk Education
B.A., LL.B., LL.M.

Jack is a licensed lawyer in Ontario with over 30 years of experience in handling professional liability claims. He was called to the Bar of Ontario in 1987 and spent the first 10 years of his legal career in private practice as a civil litigator.

In 1997, Jack transitioned in-house to work for the professional liability insurer for lawyers in Ontario, where he spent the next 21 years managing professional liability claims and overseeing an active claims department. He has also adjudicated for the federal government and, more recently, has worked with the professional liability insurer for architects in Ontario.

Basil Andrews

Claims Examiner
B.Sc., B.A., LL.B.

With more than 15 years of experience in the insurance industry, Basil has developed extensive expertise with insurance claims involving litigation. His early career as a litigator provides a solid foundation for his work in the insurance industry. Since 2014, Basil has focused on insurance litigation with multinational, national, and regional companies, specializing in professional liability and directors’ and officers’ insurance. An Osgoode Hall Law School graduate, Basil was called to the Ontario Bar in 2007.

Francois-Alexandre Godin

Claims Examiner
M.B.A, J.D., LL.B., CIP, C.Adm.

Based in British Columbia, François-Alexandre began his career in the insurance and legal industries in 2018 and has developed a specialized practice in complex liability claims and coverage analysis across Canada. Before joining CPA Plan, he worked as a Claims Consultant with a Montreal-based casualty insurer, gaining national experience in professional liability and D&O claims. Fully bilingual in French and English, he holds degrees in accounting, civil law and common law, including an MBA in financial planning, as well as the CIP designation. He is known for quickly identifying core issues, assessing risk clearly, and making sound decisions that move matters forward.

Joseph Cioffi

Claims Examiner
Hons. BComm.

Joseph is a seasoned insurance professional with over 10 years of experience managing complex litigation across professional liability, general liability, and property and casualty claims. Specializing in insurance defence and claims resolution, he is known for strategic thinking, sound judgment, and a practical approach to dispute resolution.

Over the past decade, Joseph has worked extensively with legal counsel, brokers, and insureds on high-stakes files, consistently delivering results that balance risk, cost-efficiency, and client priorities.

Simon Bernstein

Claims Examiner
B.A., LL.B.

Simon is a seasoned legal and insurance professional with over three decades of experience in the industry. He holds an Honours B.A. in English Literature from York University and a law degree from Osgoode Hall Law School. Called to the Ontario Bar in 1994, Simon began his career in insurance defence at a prominent boutique law firm before transitioning into the insurance sector. He has held senior roles at several leading organizations, specializing in professional liability and financial lines claims. A respected voice in the field, he is known for his practical insights and leadership in complex claims management.